12 Secret Santa Gifts for a Baseball Player
Last updated: December 16, 2025
#1 Insulated Tumbler with Baseball Team Design
This Algodoneros de Torreon Beisbol Stainless Steel Insulated Tumbler would make a unique Secret Santa gift for a baseball enthusiast. With its authentic Mexican Baseball Team design, dual insulated walls, and leakproof lid, it's a practical yet fun present that displays a special appreciation for the sport and the team.
#2 MLB-Themed Playing Cards Deck
As an ideal gift for baseball enthusiasts, the MasterPieces Officially Licensed MLB Playing Cards add a personalized touch to card games. The 54-card deck, featuring individualized team designs on face cards and jokers, along with a special wood cut design on the Ace of Spades, will surely impress MLB fans.
#3 Customizable Baseball Neon Wall Sign
This Personalized Baseball LED Sign would make a stellar Secret Santa gift for a baseball enthusiast. It's customizable with the recipient's name, crafted from durable metal, and features multi-colored LED lights. The size and powder coating make it suitable for both indoor and outdoor decor, adding a personalized touch to any baseball lover's home.
#4 Stadium Blueprint Print for Fans
The "Busch Stadium Blueprint Print" is a delightful piece for any baseball enthusiast, especially a Cardinals fan. The detailed hand-drawn artwork, unique architectural perspective and high-quality paper stock bring the iconic structure to life. The crisp white finish further accentuates this 18 x 24 print's aesthetic appeal.
#5 Bi-Fold Leather Baseball Wallet
The Rawlings Men's Tanned-leather Baseball Stitch Embroidered Wallet combines practical features with a sports-centric look, making it a suitable Secret Santa gift for baseball enthusiasts. With multiple compartments, ample card slots, a nostalgic quote, and distinctive baseball stitching, it skillfully blends functionality with the love for baseball, packed neatly in durable, quality leather.
#6 Tabletop Magnetic Baseball Game for Two
The "MLB Slammin' Sluggers Magnetic Baseball Tabletop Game" is a delightful pick for baseball enthusiasts. With a comprehensive play, including pitching, fielding, batting, and running bases, and customizable team options, it gives an immersive baseball experience - a great entertainer for a 2-player game night.
#7 Custom Team Logo Crew Socks
The "COLORSFORU Custom Team Logo Crew Socks" make a great Secret Santa gift for any baseball enthusiast. Personalizable with team name and number, these superior quality, moisture-wicking socks offer both comfort and style. Suitable for both men and women baseball players, they strike the right balance between aesthetics and functionality.
#8 Wooden Pinball Baseball Game
The Ambassador Games MLB Wooden Pinball Baseball Game is a fun, interactive gift for a baseball enthusiast. Its wooden design and stainless steel bat lend a quality feel. Plus, it includes personalized stickers of all MLB teams, allowing the user to customize the game with their favorite team.
#9 Cap Organizer with Two Display Options
This Hat Organizer is a space-saving dream for any baseball cap enthusiast. It can securely hold up to 20 caps, with easy accessibility and two display options. The versatility for installation is a plus, with adhesive or screws for different surfaces. A practical, aesthetic storage solution for a baseball lover.
#10 Baseball Training Tee with Popper Ball
The Bandit Sports Baseball Training Mini Tee Popper makes an excellent Secret Santa gift for baseball enthusiasts. It provides solo training flexibility and is suitable for all skill levels, from tee ball to professionals. Its design enhances hand-eye coordination but requires exclusive use of Popper Balls to ensure longevity.
#11 Baseball-Themed Bottle Opener Tool
The Baseball BBQ 'Pick Off' Bottle Opener combines a love for baseball and BBQ. It is a versatile, durable, and aesthetically appealing item with a patented wooden baseball bat handle and superior stainless steel material. Perfect for dads or baseball fans, it adds a playful twist to grilling accessories and makes for a thoughtful Secret Santa gift.
#12 Baseball Trivia Game for Players
The MasterPieces MLB Baseball Trivia Game offers an engaging and informative experience for baseball enthusiasts. With 1000 questions, this board game tests and expands players' knowledge on America's pastime. An ideal choice for any baseball fan, it's an officially licensed product ensuring fidelity to the sport.